The Golden Comment: the season's happiest comment section

Highest Fan Score: positive comments per 1,000 across the season.

This season’s winner
Kennesaw State
Owls · C-USA · 10–4
874.3
Fan Score

Questions about this award

Who won The Golden Comment this season?
Kennesaw State, at 874.3 positive comments per 1,000. Navy was runner-up at 862, with Tulsa third at 839.
How is The Golden Comment decided?
By the season's classifications alone, with no vote and no panel: every fanbase that clears the volume floor is scored on positive comments per 1,000, and the award goes to the top of that list. The median across the 120 fanbases ranked here is 600.8.
Every fanbase on this metric

Full standings

Rank
Team
Fan Score
1
Kennesaw State
C-USA · 10–4
874.3
2
Navy
American · 11–2
862
3
Tulsa
American · 4–8
839
4
New Mexico
Mountain West · 9–4
836.1
5
FIU
C-USA · 7–6
829.6
6
WKU
C-USA · 9–4
822.2
7
Wake Forest
ACC · 9–4
803.4
8
Central Michigan
MAC · 7–6
803.3
9
Bowling Green
MAC · 4–8
782.6
10
Missouri State
C-USA · 7–6
782.6
11
Utah State
Mountain West · 6–7
782.3
12
Troy
Sun Belt · 8–6
779.1
13
North Texas
American · 12–2
775.7
14
East Carolina
American · 9–4
771.6
15
Ohio
MAC · 9–4
768.5
16
Western Michigan
MAC · 10–4
765.4
17
Old Dominion
Sun Belt · 10–3
755.5
18
Hawaii
Mountain West · 9–4
753.9
19
Marshall
Sun Belt · 5–7
751.3
20
Virginia
ACC · 11–3
749.3
21
Army
American · 7–6
745.9
22
Indiana
Big Ten · 16–0
739.4
23
Temple
American · 5–7
738.9
24
North Dakota State
FCS · 12–1
737.6
25
Southern Miss
Sun Belt · 7–6
736.4
26
New Mexico State
C-USA · 4–8
734
27
Texas Tech
Big 12 · 12–2
723.4
28
TCU
Big 12 · 9–4
719.8
29
Arkansas State
Sun Belt · 7–6
717.8
30
Coastal Carolina
Sun Belt · 6–7
710.3
31
Texas State
Sun Belt · 7–6
707.8
32
Memphis
American · 8–5
703.4
33
Tulane
American · 11–3
699.3
34
Duke
ACC · 9–5
695.1
35
James Madison
Sun Belt · 12–2
695
36
Louisiana
Sun Belt · 6–7
687.6
37
Houston
Big 12 · 10–3
683.2
38
SMU
ACC · 9–4
681.5
39
UTSA
American · 7–6
681
40
Georgia Southern
Sun Belt · 7–6
679.3
41
Northwestern
Big Ten · 7–6
671.4
42
Georgia Tech
ACC · 9–4
670.1
43
Georgia
SEC · 12–2
669.9
44
Delaware
C-USA · 7–6
664.1
45
Louisiana Tech
C-USA · 8–5
662
46
Ole Miss
SEC · 13–2
662
47
UCF
Big 12 · 5–7
656.2
48
Toledo
MAC · 8–5
655.2
49
UNLV
Mountain West · 10–4
644.1
50
Arizona
Big 12 · 9–4
640
51
Louisville
ACC · 9–4
630.3
52
Washington State
Pac-12 · 7–6
627.4
53
Appalachian State
Sun Belt · 5–8
627.3
54
Vanderbilt
SEC · 10–3
622.2
55
Air Force
Mountain West · 4–8
612.1
56
South Florida
American · 9–4
608.6
57
Baylor
Big 12 · 5–7
606.5
58
Middle Tennessee
C-USA · 3–9
603.7
59
Fresno State
Mountain West · 9–4
603.3
60
Iowa
Big Ten · 9–4
600.8
61
UAB
American · 4–8
600.8
62
Liberty
C-USA · 4–8
600.6
63
BYU
Big 12 · 12–2
595.6
64
Colorado
Big 12 · 3–9
595.4
65
Washington
Big Ten · 9–4
594.6
66
Sam Houston
C-USA · 2–10
592.7
67
UConn
Independent · 9–4
585
68
Ohio State
Big Ten · 12–2
584.8
69
Oregon State
Pac-12 · 2–10
582.9
70
Tennessee
SEC · 8–5
581.4
71
NC State
ACC · 8–5
579
72
Wyoming
Mountain West · 4–8
571.7
73
Mississippi State
SEC · 5–8
562.6
74
Utah
Big 12 · 11–2
559.4
75
Auburn
SEC · 5–7
554.1
76
Oregon
Big Ten · 13–2
551.2
77
Alabama
SEC · 11–4
548.3
78
Miami
ACC · 13–3
548.3
79
Notre Dame
Independent · 10–2
546.2
80
San Diego State
Mountain West · 9–4
545.5
81
Iowa State
Big 12 · 8–4
545
82
Missouri
SEC · 8–5
542.3
83
Texas A&M
SEC · 11–2
541.6
84
Purdue
Big Ten · 2–10
538.5
85
Stanford
ACC · 4–8
538.3
86
Cincinnati
Big 12 · 7–6
535.4
87
Illinois
Big Ten · 9–4
532.6
88
Oklahoma
SEC · 10–3
524.9
89
Kentucky
SEC · 5–7
522.4
90
Pittsburgh
ACC · 8–5
520.4
91
West Virginia
Big 12 · 4–8
515.8
92
USC
Big Ten · 9–4
511.6
93
Rutgers
Big Ten · 5–7
508.6
94
San Jose State
Mountain West · 3–9
507.4
95
Arizona State
Big 12 · 8–5
499.7
96
UTEP
C-USA · 2–10
498.8
97
Oklahoma State
Big 12 · 1–11
489.4
98
Clemson
ACC · 7–6
488.9
99
Boise State
Mountain West · 9–5
487.9
100
South Carolina
SEC · 4–8
482.8
101
UCLA
Big Ten · 3–9
476.4
102
Michigan
Big Ten · 9–4
472.1
103
Texas
SEC · 10–3
468.7
104
Florida
SEC · 4–8
467.5
105
Nebraska
Big Ten · 7–6
466
106
Boston College
ACC · 2–10
462
107
Michigan State
Big Ten · 4–8
457.8
108
Kansas
Big 12 · 5–7
440.9
109
Kansas State
Big 12 · 6–6
436.3
110
Colorado State
Mountain West · 2–10
431.7
111
LSU
SEC · 7–6
425.9
112
Penn State
Big Ten · 7–6
424.9
113
Virginia Tech
ACC · 3–9
405.6
114
Minnesota
Big Ten · 8–5
396.7
115
Florida State
ACC · 5–7
390.8
116
Syracuse
ACC · 3–9
386.7
117
North Carolina
ACC · 4–8
381.7
118
Arkansas
SEC · 2–10
331.6
119
Maryland
Big Ten · 4–8
326.5
120
Wisconsin
Big Ten · 4–8
281.5
Below volume threshold: too few comments to rank on this award
–
South Alabama
Sun Belt · 4–8
–
–
UMass
MAC · 0–12
–
–
Charlotte
American · 1–11
–
–
Rice
American · 5–8
–
–
Florida Atlantic
American · 4–8
–
–
Nevada
Mountain West · 3–9
–
–
Miami (Ohio)
MAC · 7–7
–
–
Northern Illinois
MAC · 3–9
–
–
Akron
MAC · 5–7
–
–
UL Monroe
Sun Belt · 3–9
–
–
Ball State
MAC · 4–8
–
–
Kent State
MAC · 5–7
–
–
Sacramento State
FCS · 7–5
–
–
California
ACC · 7–6
–
–
Jacksonville State
C-USA · 9–5
–
–
Buffalo
MAC · 5–7
–
–
Georgia State
Sun Belt · 1–11
–
–
Eastern Michigan
MAC · 4–8
–

120 of 138 fanbases rank on this metric; the rest are listed under the ranked set without a rank, never ranked last.

This award tracks the Fan Score leaderboard, where you can filter by conference.

Behind the numbers

Sence read 2,498,712 college-football comments to build this site. It can read yours.